The Holland House

I’ve been kind of obsessed with oyster forks lately, most likely as a result of my earlier post “Aw Shucks…It’s an Oyster Obsession”.  I’ve found a couple of Gorham forks which are rather interesting, to me at least.  What I find fascinating about the following two forks is that they were made about the same period of time (so I believe).

Two Gorham Oyster Forks Circa 1890

Two Gorham Oyster Forks Circa 1890

The uppermost fork is sleek, clean, contemporary, modernistic.  Although I cannot determine the pattern, my research indicates that it was made in the late 1880s, perhaps for Delmonico’s restaurant.  The other fork is in the “Saxony” pattern, designed by George Wilkinson and patented in 1891.  I would expect this Saxony design to have been manufactured in 1891, but the other…no way.  Ah, such is the fun of collecting silverplate! But what was that crest on the front of the handle of the Saxony fork?

Crest on Handle of Saxony Fork

Crest on Handle of Saxony Fork

And what did the names on the back of the handle signify, “H. M. Kinsley & Baumann”?

Who Were H. M. Kinsley & Baumann

Who Were H. M. Kinsley & Baumann?

Actually, unlike a good deal of my research, this information was relatively easy to track down.  Herbert M. Kinsley and one of his sons-in-law, Gustav Baumann, owned the Holland House hotel which opened in New York City at the corner of 5th Avenue and 30th Street in 1891 (same year the Saxony pattern was patented). Gustav Baumann, Gustav Baumann, gee that name sounded so familiar.  And then it hit me, Gustav Baumann later went on to establish the Biltmore Hotel in New York City.  I wrote a blog a while back “I’m In Love With Jack” about Gustav Baumann and his associate Jack Bowman (the Jack in the blog title).  Weird how one blog (oyster forks) leads me to an earlier blog (Jack). So, research shows that Herbert Kinsley was a successful caterer and restauranteur in Chicago before he came to New York and opened the Holland House along with his son-in-law, Gustav.  (Note:  Herbert Kinsley wrote a book entitled “One Hundred Recipes for the Chafing Dish” which was published by Gorham.  This book is for sale at my Etsy shop here: ). They gave their guests a 33 page booklet about the Holland House when the hotel opened.

Front Page of Holland House Booklet

Front Page of Holland House Booklet

Note that the crest on the front page looks similar to that on the oyster fork.

Front Portico

Front Portico

The Holland House was majestic in every way and was one of the finest hotels in the world at that time. 

Dining Room


Herbert Kinsley died just three years later as a result of a surgical operation gone bad.   In 1911 Gustav retired from the hotel business but came out of retirement in 1914 to run the new Biltmore Hotel.  In October of 1914, he was reported to be making his daily inspection of the hotel when he fell to his death from a parapet.  His secretary, John Bowman, became general manager of the New York Biltmore upon Gustav’s death.  John “Jack” Bowman went on the build many more Biltmore hotels and had a very successful career in the hotel field.

Jack Bowman and a Gorham "Biltmore Hotels 1931" Fork

Jack Bowman and a Gorham “Biltmore Hotels 1931” Fork

The two oyster forks in the first photo and the Biltmore Hotel fork shown above are available for sale at my Etsy shop. One last note….in 1894 Herbert Kinsley wrote a cookbook of chafing dish recipes which was published by Gorham.  Now I’m obsessed with chafing dishes.  More on that in another post!  Know you can’t wait.  

This entry was posted in Biltmore, gorham, Gustav Baumann, Gustave Baumann, H M Kinsley, Herbert M Kinsley, Holland House, Jack Bowman, john bowman, oyster fork and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The Holland House

  1. Thomas Wheelock says:

    I admire the thoroughness of your research. I can see you clearly take enormous pleasure in the very process. How wonderful it is to flesh things out and enjoy the resultant roundness of an event, event in the broadest of senses, as more and more information is appended.

    Thank you

  2. KerryCan says:

    The way you tell these stories makes the hotel, and silver, world seems so small and familiar! It’s really interesting that the same names keep coming up. It amazes me that first oyster fork is from the late 1800s–it looks so modern!

  3. Peg Trillo says:

    Hi, I too found your information really interesting. I have a tray that is marked Kinsley and Baumann 1891, Gotham Co. I was wondering if you can tell me how much it is worth. It has the same crest that is on the saxony spoon. Thank you.

    • queenofsienna says:

      Hello! I think perhaps your tray is marked “Gorham” not “Gotham”. There was a Gotham Silver Co. but they were in business from approximately 1920 to 1950 and your tray is marked Kinsley & Baumann 1891 with the Holland House crest, long before Gotham began.

      The value of the tray depends on condition, size and desirability. I suggest you look at sold items on eBay for ” Gorham tray silverplate” to see if any listings resemble your tray in size, design and condition. That will give you an idea of interest and pricing.

      There are collectors of hotel and restaurant ware who might be interested. And anyone with the Kinsley or Baumann name might be interested.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s