Persian versus Jewell

I was looking at my Etsy listing for two Persian pattern silver plated nut picks recently and I was reminded that while the patterns of these two nut picks were similar…they were not exactly the same.

My Two Persian Pattern Nut Picks

My Two Persian Pattern Nut Picks

The pick on the bottom of the photo above has a background of fine little lines in the round section whereas the pick on the top does not, it has a dark patina but no textured lines.  The swirling detail toward the tip of the handle is more finely detailed on the bottom pick than the top pick.  The bottom pick has no maker’s mark; the top pick is marked “Rogers & Bro.” within the circle.

Back View of My Two Nut Picks

Back View of My Two Nut Picks

As you can see in the photo above, the unmarked pick has the same lined circle area on the back as it does on the front.

When I had originally listed these picks, I had researched the pattern and noted at that time that there was also another pattern, called “Jewell” that was very similar to “Persian”.  They appeared to be almost identical on some sites.  Perhaps one of these picks was really “Jewell”?  It was time to do more research.

1870 Persian Patent #4348

1870 Persian Patent #4348

 

The patent drawing above is for  the 1870 patent #4348 obtained by C.D. Hall and assigned to Bristol Brass; this is the patent for “Persian”.  The back of the round area has the lines. 

I have not been able to find a patent for “Jewell”; the date attributed to this pattern is 1882…as I have not found a patent, I have not been able to confirm that either.  Simpson, Hall, Miller & Co. was one of the manufactureres of the “Jewell” pattern.

Tere Hagen has a drawing of “Jewell” in her book “Silverplated Flatware” and I’ve positioned that drawing next to the drawing of “Persian” from the patent.

Persian / Jewell Comparison

Persian / Jewell Comparison

When you see the two patterns side by side, you can easily notice the differences.  I definitely had two “Persian” pattern nut picks; there were slight variations but that sometimes happens in the manufacturing process.  But there are definitely similarities between the two patterns.  I was reminded of the court case between Gorham and LeRoy White, designer.

Gorham 1861 "Cottage" Pattern Patent

Gorham 1861 “Cottage” Pattern Patent

 Gorham sued LeRoy White, designer, for patent infringement.  Gorham’s patent # 1440 for what was known as the “Cottage” pattern is above.

LeRoy White 1867 "Gothic" Pattern Patent #2551

LeRoy White 1867 “Gothic” Pattern Patent #2551

The first of LeRoy White’s patents (1867) for the pattern known as “Gothic” is shown above.

LeRoy White 1868 Patent #2992, "Gothic" Revised

LeRoy White 1868 Patent #2992, “Gothic” Revised

The following year, Mr. White applied for another patent, modifying his earlier design.

Gorham and White Designs - Side by Side Comparison

Gorham and White Designs – Side by Side Comparison

For ease of comparison, I’ve placed all three designs next to each other.  This case introduced the “Ordinary Observer” test.  According to the “Ordinary Observer” test, there is infringement “if in the eye of an ordinary observer, giving such attention as a purchaser usually gives, two designs are substantially the same, the resemblance is such as to deceive such an observer, inducing him to purchase one supposing it to be the other.”  Gorham prevailed in this suit.

So, if someone were using a “Jewell” pattern nut pick at one end of the table and another person were using a “Persian” pattern nut pick at the other end of the table, would the “ordinary observer” notice the difference?  I think not.  As far as I know, a lawsuit was not filed in this case.

My “Persian” nut picks are available at my Etsy shop here:

https://www.etsy.com/listing/99448146/two-silver-plated-nut-picks-rogers-bro

Nut picks work wonderfully for olive picks as well!

"Persian" Pattern Nut Pick Used as Olive Pick in Martini

“Persian” Pattern Nut Pick Used as Olive Pick in Martini

Add a touch of Victoriana to your cocktail and see my post on “The Victorian Bar”.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Cottage pattern, Etsy, flatware, gorham, Gothic pattern, Jewell pattern, LeRoy White, martini, nut pick, olive pick, ordinary observer, Persian pattern, queenofsienna, Rogers & Bro., silver plate, silver plated, silverplate, Simpson Hall Miller, Victorian bar and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s